A Tragic Lack of Restraint

I have spent some time in Switzerland, and I have a bit of insight into the causes of the New Year’s Eve tragedy in Switzerland .

The first time was in 1970. I was young but not quite stupid, and I was astounded at the (literally) underground nightclub scene in old WWII bunkers beneath the major cities. Mobs of mostly teenage kids drinking and smoking in venues designed to keep people out, not let them escape. Fueled by a general sense of rebellion and release. A recipe for a disaster.

My other pertinent visit was New Year’s 1994, when I was travelling with my family. We were staying in a little ski village up the valley from the Matterhorn, and to celebrate the occasion we went to a restaurant for Swiss fondue, and then to the main square for the cultural experience.

It was a classic Alpine scene, with snow-crusted ancient buildings and a few flakes drifting down. And everybody was out enjoying it. Loudly.  A nearby vacant lot was a favourite spot, with people setting off every form of firework you can imagine in all directions. One guy drove the spike on the rocket into the snow, lit the fuse and jumped back. The rocket immediately fell over and took off, zooming across the lot to explode against the building on the other side. I found my family a shop front with a solid overhang, and we stood safely and observed the scene.

The European Attitude

I have noticed that most European societies have a different attitude from North Americans. They are quite accepting of all sorts of controls and regulations we would consider impinging on our freedoms, but on the other hand, people are much more responsible for their own safety. For example, many of the historical buildings have seriously exposed walkways and staircases with no handrails. Nobody seems worried about lawsuits.

I have been told that Switzerland bans private use of fireworks completely except for New Year’s Eve. With predictable results.

The deaths in Crans-Montana follow the pattern perfectly. An overcrowded bar with patrons as young as fourteen, an ancient building with poor egress, a lax attitude towards alcohol consumption, and a highly regulated society with its safety valve temporarily removed. Boom.

The Bottom Line

As I discuss in my book on the subject, “Why Are People so Stupid?” when the emotions take over (especially when helped by alcohol) intelligence and moderation go out the window, and somebody pays the price.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.