Fantasy, Reality, Reviews and Drama Lessons from Gordon A. Long
Products: fantasy books, social commentary, ebooks, humor, reviews, and short stories. 
Self-publishing services: editing, proof-reading, graphic art, formatting, and promoting e books or traditional books. 
Drama: for teachers of spoken language, drama, and second languages improving classroom skills and resources.
 

   Home      Appeal of Clouds
Are We Stupid? Blog admits "Why Canadians Fear Bernie Sanders"
Renaissance Writer reviews a whole genre, the "To Hell with Convention" Book.
Indies Unlimited Post "Find and Replace: the Writer's Best Friend”
YouTube Video "Out of Mischief Trailer"
YouTube Video "On the Road in Southeast Asia" the vibrant street life of the bustling cities of Cambodia and Vietnam.
YouTube Video  "The Rhyme of the Swiftsure Mariner"  For any sailor who ever had a race where the wind just wouldn't cooperate.
YouTube Video  "To The Ends of Argentina"   Travel to Iguassu Falls and Cape Horn

Books

Why Are People So Stupid?

 eBook $2.99

 amazon.com

A Sword Called…Kitten?

 eBook: $1.99

Smashwords.com 

Soft Cover: $14.95

Amazon.com

 


Drama Materials

Expressive Poetry Performance

   Student Handbook

   Teacher Guide

The Dramatic Classroom Blog

Latest post: Get the "Amateur" off the Board of Directors


Interesting Contacts

Cas Peace -  Novelist, Editor
 
Kaz Augustin  -  Sandalpress
 
Yvonne Hertzberger  - Fantasy Writer 

The Indie View - Indie Book Reviews from Around the Web
 

Anachronism Pictures

Including the award-winning mechanical squid,"Septopus"
 

Generations

The Surrey Intergenerational Theatre Troupe
 

The Vaudevillians

 B. C's. #1 Seniors Entertainment Troupe

 


 

The Uncommon Appeal of Clouds

By

Alexander McCall Smith

 

It has long been my observation that the division of books into genres, while superficially useful, can be a rather misleading practice. Science fiction, for example, is actually a setting, not a genre. Thus we have sci-fi detective stories, sci-fi romances, sci-fi westerns, etc. Detective mysteries tend to lean towards the “novel” category, because they are intrinsically about people and their reasons for doing what they do.

Since the characterization is the part of the detective novel that has always appealed to me, I find the crime element (especially murder) to be extrinsic and often intrusive to my enjoyment of the story. Thus I have lately become entranced by two crime novelists who downplay the detective-solves-crime element of the story. Instead they concentrate on the important part, the interplay of humanity, which constitutes the major interest of our lives, both real and in entertainment.

Donna Leon is one such writer. Her Commissario Brunetti series is much more about Venice, Italian politics, and Brunetti and his relationships than it is about the crimes he solves.

It turns out that Alexander McCall Smith is another. He is renown for his “Number One Ladies Detective Agency,” series, which emphasizes the social interplay of the people of Botswana. Incidentally, it seems, actual mysteries get solved.

McCall Smith’s “Isabel Dalhousie” series pushes the envelope even further.

Isabel Dalhousie is an unlikely detective. She doesn’t intend to be one; she just helps people. Isabel is a philosopher, given to meandering away down those wonderful side streets of surmise that all thoughtful people wander into at times.

So when someone mentions the ubiquitous cucumber sandwich, her mind leaps to wondering if there might be a culture where cucumbers are spurned. Which leads her to consider England’s earlier dislike of apples (for bibilical reasons), and thence to the concern that potatoes were connected to laziness. Leading the reader to wonder whether that specific myth was created by the English to explain the actions of the poor in Ireland, which is exactly the kind of off-the-topic thought that this series inspires. But when we learn that one of the conflicts of the story is between the capitalist father and his socialist son, we begin to recognize the skill of a writer who can turn us loose in our own thoughts, but suddenly find us exactly where he wants us to be.

Lost in these flights of philosophical fancy, Isabel often finds herself smiling, chuckling, and even making comments that attract reactions of puzzlement or misunderstanding, which she is then forced to explain. Or not, if that is what she prefers. She is a philosopher, after all. Since the whole story takes place firmly in her point of view, the reader is often led to wonder what kind of endearing kook the other characters see her as. Their appreciation of her services is unquestioned, although her methods must seem obscure.

In “The Uncommon Appeal of Clouds” she is asked to help Duncan Munrowe, who is robbed of his prized possession, a Poussin oil of considerable value. It doesn’t take much digging around to realize that the main suspects are Duncan’s son and daughter, each of whom cheerfully accuses the other. Between solving all sorts of problems for acquaintances, friends, and even herself, Isabel applies no detective skills or techniques, but solves the problem of the missing painting through a philosophical trick worthy of Solomon.

And that's the whole plot. The reason I am giving you so little is that this is not really what the novel is about.

Enjoyment of this sort of book depends on the philosophy that the journey is more important than the goal. Isabel’s philosophical bent prepares us for the possibility that there will be no straightforward solutions to life’s problems, and yet we leave the novel satisfied that life is moving in its proper channels anyway.

An entertaining and satisfying read, with an uncommon appeal of its own.


Back to Reviews 

TOP         

  

 


 


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


Novel 
and
Television series
 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


Mind of the Beast

Brian and Juliet Freyermuth


As Chimney Sweepers Come to Dust

Alan Bradley


Raven's Wing

Shawna Reppert


Hooligans

Chaz Fenwick


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
 


 
Erik Kort


 
(Short Story)

Aine Greaney


Mysteries of Shetland

Anne Cleeves


Ravensblood

Shawna Reppert


The Cold Forever

Dmitry Pavlovsky


Ava's Man

Rick Bragg


Ava's Man

Rick Bragg


The Best Laid Plans

Terry Fallis

 

 

Wordscapist: the Myth

Arpan Panicker


Murder and Mendelssohn
Kerry Greenwood

Drawing Conclusions
Donna Leon

The Minor Adjustment Beauty Salon
Alexander McCall Smith

The Dead in their Vaulted Arches
Alan Bradley


The Commons Book 1

The Journeyman
Michael Alan Peck


At War With Satan
Steff Metal

Phobos: Mayan Fear
Steve Alten

Guystuff
Linton Robinson

The Great Gatsby
F. Scott Fitzgerald

You Can't Get There From Here
Gayle Forman

Psychic Warrior
T. D. McKinnon

Forager
Peter R. Stone

Butterman (Time Travel) Inc.
PK Hrezo

Winter Fire
Laurie Dubay 

Canadian Pie
Will Ferguson 

Bertie Plays the Blues
Alexander McCall Smith

Miss Timmins' School for Girls
Nayana Currimbhoy

Xenophobia
Peter Cawdron

The Twelve Rooms of the Nile
Enid Shomer

The Importance of Being Seven
Alexander McCall Smith

Cupcakes, Trinkets, and Other Deadly Magic
Meghan Ciana Doidge

Unnatural Habits
A Phryne Fisher Mystery

Kerry Greenwood

Strays
Book I of The Glaring Chronicles

Matthew Krause

The Hundred-Foot Journey
Richard C. Morais

The Crooked House
John Longeway

Eye Candy
by
Ryan Schneider

Season of the Harvest
Michael R. Hicks

Chronicles of Trellah Book I:
The Perpetual Rain

T. S. Graham


The Casual Vacancy
J. K. Rowling
Alexander McCall Smith
Charlotte Henley Babb

David Litwack 
G. T. Denny
John Patrick Gallagher
Cas Peace
Steve Umstead
L.M.Dewalt
J.W.Bacarro
Mark Everett Stone